Toy Story 5 Tops Box Office, Supergirl Disappoints
Toy Story 5 leads box office, Supergirl opens low

The box office saw a significant upset this weekend, with Toy Story 5 maintaining its top spot and Supergirl opening to a disappointing $40M domestic. This comes as a surprise, given the hype surrounding the film. The low opening can be attributed to the finicky nature of fanboys and fangirls when it comes to big screen superhero properties.
What happened
Toy Story 5 is still ruling the box office, with a second weekend around $70M+ depending on the turnout from families. However, Supergirl filed a lower-than-expected $40M domestic opening. The global start looks to hover around $75M, with $11M so far abroad from 78 markets and 40,000 screens. CinemaScore was a B-, which is lower than other DC films.
The definite recommend on Screen Engine/Rentrak's PostTrak is 52%, which is low for a planned summer tentpole of this magnitude. Men gave Supergirl a very low definite recommend at 45%, while women were slightly better at 62%. Tracking firms saw this coming, with Supergirl being one of the wobbly event films this summer.
Why it matters
The low opening of Supergirl has significant implications for the film industry. It highlights the challenges of expanding demographics beyond older men and the importance of having a sticky marketing campaign. James Gunn and Peter Safran are tasked with delivering filmmaker-driven fare that isn't cookie cutter, and this film's performance may impact their strategy.
ProsCons
- Toy Story 5's success shows that family-friendly films can still perform well.
- Supergirl's unique storyline and female-led cast could have appealed to a wider audience.
- The film's low opening may lead to a re-evaluation of the DC Studios' strategy.
- Supergirl's low opening may be a sign of toxicity among fanboys and critics towards female-led superhero films.
- The film's marketing campaign may not have been effective in appealing to a broader audience.
- The low opening may impact the future of the DC Extended Universe.
How to think about it
When evaluating the success of a film, it's essential to consider the various factors that contribute to its performance. This includes the marketing campaign, the target audience, and the overall quality of the film. In the case of Supergirl, it's clear that the film's low opening was due to a combination of these factors.
FAQ
What is the current box office ranking?+
What are the implications of Supergirl's low opening?+
What can be learned from this experience?+
Streaming availability changes constantly. Check where it's playing right now — subscription, rent, or buy:
- boxoffice·3 min readMegyn Kelly on Supergirl Box Office Bomb
Megyn Kelly celebrates Supergirl box office bomb
- boxoffice·3 min readMarvel Blockbusters Dominate Box Office
Marvel movies lead box office trends
- boxoffice·3 min readSpider-Man: Brand New Day Posts $930M Opening, Surpasses Zack Snyder's Top DC Film
Spider-Man: Brand New Day earned about $930 million worldwide in its debut, overtaking Zack Snyder’s highest‑grossing DC title.